📊 مقارنة الباندات — Band 5 vs Band 6.5

شوف الفرق الحقيقي — بعين الممتحن

السؤال: يعتقد البعض أن الجامعات يجب أن تركز على التدريب الأكاديمي فقط، بينما يرى آخرون أنها يجب أن تطور المهارات العملية أيضاً. ما رأيك؟
🔴 Band 5

I think universities are very important. They teach students many things. Students learn academic subjects and also practical skills. Universities should teach both things. This is good for students. When students graduate they need both academic knowledge and practical skills. Employers want employees with both. So universities should teach everything. This will help students in their future. Universities have a big role in this. Education is important for everyone. I believe universities should teach both academic and practical things.

❌ تكرار المعلومات
نفس الفكرة تتكرر مرات عديدة بطرق مختلفة بدون إضافة معلومات جديدة
❌ بناء الفقرة
فقرة واحدة فقط بدون تقسيم منطقي أو تسلسل واضح للأفكار
❌ المفردات البسيطة
"important", "teach", "students" — كلمات بسيطة جداً بدون كلمات أكاديمية
❌ الروابط الضعيفة
استخدام "so" و "and" فقط — حاجة لروابط أقوى مثل "Furthermore", "Consequently"
❌ عدم الإجابة الكاملة
لم يناقش الطالب وجهة النظر المعاكسة أو يقدم حجج قوية
🟢 Band 6.5

While some argue that universities should prioritize purely academic education, I strongly believe that institutions must balance theoretical knowledge with practical skill development. This perspective is crucial for preparing graduates who can effectively contribute to society.

Undeniably, academic knowledge forms the foundation of higher education. Universities excel at cultivating critical thinking and providing specialized expertise. However, this foundation becomes incomplete without real-world application. Contemporary employers increasingly demand graduates with hands-on experience. For instance, engineering graduates require laboratory experience, and business students benefit from internship programs. Furthermore, practical skills enhance students' confidence and employability prospects.

In conclusion, universities should not abandon academic rigor. Rather, they should integrate practical training alongside traditional curriculum. This comprehensive approach ensures graduates possess both theoretical understanding and marketable competencies, ultimately benefiting individuals and the broader economy.

✅ هيكل واضح
مقدمة + جسم الموضوع + خاتمة — بناء فقرات منطقي وسهل المتابعة
✅ مفردات متقدمة
"prioritize", "cultivating", "contemporary", "marketable" — مفردات أكاديمية قوية
✅ روابط قوية
"Furthermore", "However", "Rather" — روابط تربط الأفكار بشكل احترافي
✅ أمثلة محددة
ذكر أمثلة واقعية (engineering, internship) لدعم الحجج
✅ إجابة متوازنة
اعترف بأهمية العلم الأكاديمي لكن أضاف رؤية متوازنة

📊 المقارنة والدرجات

معايير التقييم Band 5 Band 6.5
Task Achievement 6/9 8/9
Coherence & Cohesion 5/9 7/9
Lexical Resource 4/9 6/9
Grammatical Accuracy 5/9 6/9
السؤال: يقول البعض أن التكنولوجيا تحسن حياتنا، بينما يعتقد آخرون أنها تسبب مشاكل. ما رأيك أنت؟
🔴 Band 5

Technology is everywhere today. It makes life easier. People use technology every day. They use phones and computers. Technology is good for people. It helps them work and study. But technology has problems too. Some people use it too much. They spend too much time on phones. This is bad for health. Children watch screens all day. This is not good. Technology can be good or bad. It depends on how people use it. We should use technology wisely. Technology is important but we need balance.

❌ جمل قصيرة مملة
جمل بسيطة جداً بدون تنوع في البناء أو طول الجملة
❌ تكرار الكلمات
"technology" و "people" تتكرر باستمرار بدون استخدام ضمائر أو كلمات بديلة
❌ أفكار غير مطورة
الأفكار مذكورة لكن بدون شرح عميق أو دعم بأمثلة
❌ لا توجد نتيجة واضحة
الكاتب لم يأخذ موقفاً واضحاً أو يقدم خلاصة قوية
🟢 Band 6.5

Technology undoubtedly pervades modern society, yet its impact remains contentious. While some emphasize the revolutionary benefits of technological advancement, others highlight its detrimental consequences. In my view, technology yields substantial advantages that outweigh its drawbacks when utilized responsibly.

The benefits of technology are extensively documented. Digital platforms have revolutionized communication, enabling instant global connectivity. Educational technology democratizes access to knowledge, allowing students worldwide to access quality learning resources. Furthermore, technological innovations in healthcare have prolonged life expectancy and improved treatment efficacy.

Conversely, technology's negative aspects warrant consideration. Excessive screen time correlates with mental health issues and diminished social interactions. Additionally, cyber-threats and data privacy concerns pose significant challenges in the digital age.

Nevertheless, these problems stem not from technology itself, but from its misuse. With appropriate regulation and digital literacy education, we can maximize technological benefits whilst minimizing risks. Therefore, technology remains fundamentally beneficial to society.

✅ بناء متقدم
أربع فقرات منظمة: مقدمة، فوائد، تحديات، خلاصة مع موقف واضح
✅ مفردات متخصصة
"pervades", "contentious", "efficacy", "correlates" — مفردات أكاديمية عالية
✅ جمل معقدة
استخدام جمل بندية معقدة وتوازي نحوي محترف
✅ توازن الحجج
عرض وجهات نظر متعددة ثم الرد عليها بحجج قوية
✅ موقف واضح
موقف محدد منذ البداية وتعزيزه طوال النص

📊 المقارنة والدرجات

معايير التقييم Band 5 Band 6.5
Task Achievement 5/9 7/9
Coherence & Cohesion 4/9 8/9
Lexical Resource 3/9 7/9
Grammatical Accuracy 4/9 7/9
السؤال: يؤثر التغير المناخي على بيئتنا بشكل خطير. من يجب أن يتحمل المسؤولية — الحكومات أم الأفراد؟
🔴 Band 5

Climate change is a big problem. The environment is getting worse. We need to do something about it. The government should help. But people should also help. Everyone needs to protect the environment. We should stop using cars. We should use buses and trains. People should not waste water. The government should make laws. Companies should be careful about pollution. We all have responsibility. If we don't act now the situation will be very bad. Future generations need a clean environment. Climate change will cause problems like floods and storms. We must work together to save our planet.

❌ إجابة غير مركزة
السؤال يطلب من يتحمل المسؤولية لكن الجواب يقول "كلاهما" بدون تمييز واضح
❌ أمثلة سطحية
الأمثلة عامة جداً (لا تستخدم السيارات، وفر الماء) بدون شرح عميق
❌ كلمات بسيطة
لا توجد مفردات متقدمة تتعلق بالبيئة أو العلوم
❌ تطور ضعيف للأفكار
الأفكار مجرد قائمة بدون ربط منطقي أو تسلسل
🟢 Band 6.5

Climate change presents an unprecedented environmental crisis demanding multi-faceted solutions. While individual actions contribute to mitigation efforts, I firmly contend that governments bear primary responsibility for addressing this catastrophic phenomenon through systemic policy reform and international cooperation.

Governmental intervention proves indispensable due to the scale of climate change. Individual behavioral modifications, while commendable, cannot counteract industrial emissions and deforestation. Governments possess the legislative authority to enforce emissions standards, regulate multinational corporations, and allocate funding toward renewable energy infrastructure. For instance, the Paris Agreement exemplifies how collective governmental action can establish binding environmental commitments.

However, individual responsibility remains instrumental. Consumer choices—such as reducing carbon footprints through sustainable consumption—create market demand for green products. Educational campaigns by governments can catalyze behavioral change and foster environmental consciousness among populations.

In conclusion, while citizens must embrace sustainability, governments occupy the strategic position to implement transformative policies. Effective climate action requires complementary efforts: governmental leadership establishing the framework and individuals executing sustainable practices within that structure.

✅ موقف واضح ومركز
"governments bear primary responsibility" — رأي محدد وليس "كلاهما"
✅ حجج مفصلة
شرح لماذا يتحمل المسؤولية مع حجج مدعومة بأمثلة (Paris Agreement)
✅ مفردات متقدمة
"indispensable", "mitigation", "commendable", "catalyze" — كلمات عالية الستوى
✅ التوازن والإنصاف
الاعتراف بأهمية الأفراد لكن مع تأكيد دور الحكومات
✅ خلاصة قوية
الخلاصة تركب الأفكار معاً بطريقة متكاملة وواضحة

📊 المقارنة والدرجات

معايير التقييم Band 5 Band 6.5
Task Achievement 5/9 8/9
Coherence & Cohesion 4/9 8/9
Lexical Resource 3/9 7/9
Grammatical Accuracy 5/9 7/9
تبي توصل باند 6.5؟ ابدأ دورة الكتابة